On Saturday, October 24, 98 of the 99 members of Hirshabelle’s House voted at Jowhar for the state’s president. The count was 81 for the incumbent, Ali Abdullahi Hussein “Guudlaawe”, 13 for Nur Ilmi Halane, and four spoiled ballots, Dawan Africa reported. Guudlaawe thanked his rival, saying, in Dawan’s account, that “we have all won.” He said there had not been one day of disagreement in Hirshabelle in five years, and thanked federal officials who attended. That night, crowds in Mogadishu’s public squares at Taleex and Boondheere celebrated the result, FTL Somalia reported.
Before the vote, from Beledweyne, the state’s vice president, Yusuf Ahmed Hagar, known as Dabageed, had said that no result from Jowhar binds Hiiraan, according to WardheerNews. He is a Hawadle politician from Hiiraan and had said he would stay in office until an inclusive political agreement is reached. The state’s president spoke of five years without a day of disagreement. Its vice president called the vote a sham. The two statements came within a day of each other.
This piece asks what that gap means. Hirshabelle’s vote follows a pattern, and the ruling party’s candidate has won every time. Galmudug’s court case gives a checklist for judging how a state vote is run, and Hirshabelle’s record against it is mixed. My reading is that a procedurally clean vote cannot settle a dispute over who holds the presidency, and that the way Villa Somalia, the presidential palace, treats the three states shows why.
Three states, three outcomes
President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s government pressed all three states where it holds sway. Each president answered differently. Two are out of the contest. One is the ruling party’s candidate, and the winner.
South West’s Abdiaziz Laftagareen refused. He broke with the president over constitutional changes that would extend federal terms from four years to five, and he held his own re-election on March 28. Federal troops entered Baidoa on March 30, and he resigned that day and fled to Nairobi. Ten weeks later, Adan Madobe was elected president in the same city with the federal government’s full backing, as reported in The Guarantee. Laftagareen never accepted the outcome. His forces attacked Baidoa on August 17, September 3 and September 28; MSF said the latest round killed three people and wounded 69.
Galmudug’s Ahmed Abdi Kariye, known as Qoor Qoor, did not fight. On June 25 he said he would not seek re-election, after talks involving the intelligence chief and the prime minister. Three days later the ruling party named Liibaan Shuluq as its sole candidate. The Supreme Court threw out the July vote, Galmudug voted again on the same day as Hirshabelle, and on October 22 its House elected Liibaan president. The sequence is laid out in a September 3 investigation.
Guudlaawe took the other road. In April he and the president agreed that he would run again on the ruling party’s ticket. The party then made him its candidate. The president who cooperated was permitted to stay. Motive is unproven, but the chronology speaks for itself.
The rule is not limited to the states. In Mogadishu it produced a Speaker. Abdulkadir Mohamed Nur Jaamac was Hassan Sheikh’s preferred candidate for a South West seat in 2021 and 2022, but Laftagareen blocked him. Ten days after federal troops removed Laftagareen, a Baidoa seat that had never been put to a vote was reassigned, and Jaamac, a minister, was sworn into it. On August 11 he became Speaker, 142 votes to 30, in a ballot lawmakers from Puntland and Jubaland boycotted. The methods shift, with troops in one region, a party ticket in another and a lopsided majority in a third, but the destination is the same. If Hassan Sheikh wants you in office, you get there.
The Hawadle split
Dabageed says Hassan Sheikh abandoned an understanding that the Hawadle would be considered for the presidency. According to FTL Somalia, he told a Hawadle gathering that Hassan Sheikh had promised him years earlier that he would lead Hirshabelle, then told him the choice had gone to Guudlaawe. The same report adds that in August Hassan Sheikh asked Hawadle elders to agree on one candidate, and they authorized him to choose, which is now read as an endorsement of Guudlaawe.
The Hawadle are not speaking with one voice. A Hawadle political council led by former Hirshabelle president Ali Abdullahi Osoble backs Guudlaawe and the election. On September 12, hundreds rallied in Beledweyne for Guudlaawe. On September 21 other Hawadle leaders said no election lacking consensus can take place anywhere in Hiiraan, and on September 24 hundreds marched against it. The ruling party put a Hiiraan figure on its ticket, the former regional governor Abdifatah Hassan Afrah, as its candidate for deputy. He won the vice-presidency on October 24, 79 votes to 16.
What Galmudug’s court case means for Hirshabelle
The Supreme Court’s findings in Galmudug work as a checklist. The calendar is the first item. Galmudug’s vote moved twice, and the court said that left too little time. Hirshabelle’s vote also moved, from August 20 to September 30, because registration was unfinished in four Hiiraan districts. The final voter list was due September 19, 11 days before polling, which beats Galmudug’s July register, still open two days out. But the timetable gave about 30 days’ notice, and I found no report confirming the list went out on time.
The register is the second. The Galmudug court looked hard at registration, and in Hirshabelle registration is where the fight happened. On September 1, armed Macawisley fighters took over a registration site at a Beledweyne school and said they would not allow an election without consensus. They led the 2022 uprising against al-Shabaab in Hiiraan. A registration centre was attacked on September 7, killing one person and wounding two, FTL Somalia reported, and the Somali Digest also reports it. I found no published count of Beledweyne residents on the register.
The third is party agents. Galmudug’s case turned on representatives kept out of polling stations. Hirshabelle set September 24 for accrediting agents and September 26 for observers. But the Hawadle leaders opposing the vote are not monitoring and contesting results. They reject the process entirely. A Galmudug-style legal challenge needs an active participant armed with evidence, which a group that stays out will not have. That is my own analysis, not the court’s, and Kaab TV makes the same point: validity can only be tested by a formal complaint to the court. None has been reported.
The fourth is capacity. The commission ran Banadir, then South West, and on September 30 ran two states on the same day. The Galmudug court did not rule on capacity, but it did say a failure at one stage can sink the whole election. The fifth is politics. The Galmudug court addressed procedure, not the core political struggle, and in Hirshabelle that struggle is the real story. A procedurally flawless election cannot resolve the dispute over who holds the presidency.
The count, and could it have gone differently?
The commission announced results on October 3. The Justice and Solidarity Party (JSP) won 78 of the 99 House seats and 158 of the 222 council seats, Dawan Africa reported. On October 19 the Supreme Court certified the 78 seats, Hiiraan Online reported, saying no challenge was filed within the legal period. Galmudug was the opposite: there the court voided the first vote after a challenge. The 99 members took the oath on October 20 and the House chose its speaker on October 22. Guudlaawe was the likely winner, because he carried the ticket of the JSP, which is led by Hassan Sheikh. In 2020 he had won his first term by 86 votes to 13, backed by then-President Farmaajo.
Could it have gone differently? The president could have honoured the understanding Dabageed describes, or told the Hawadle plainly that it would not hold, before the registration fights. The commission could have set the register and the polling-station results out in public. The Hawadle leaders who stayed out could have filed a complaint, which would have put their case before the court that voided Galmudug’s vote. All three costs were small compared with what a rejected result may now cost. The best case for the other side is that the commission ran an election amid curfews and armed tension, that the court certified the result, and that the Hawadle rejection is a clan negotiation and not an electoral failing. That is a fair reading of the paper trail. But the paper trail is not what Hiiraan’s elders are rejecting.
The commission has not published polling-station results or a registration count for each Hiiraan district, and I found no statement from the Hiiraan elders’ forum on the result. What happens in Hiiraan, not in Jowhar, will show whether the state has settled who governs it. How Hirshabelle is dealing with the aftermath, including a reported Al-Shabaab agreement with Hawadle elders, is in Hirshabelle After the Vote.
Read the companion story: Galmudug’s Rerun Kept the Same Referee and the Same Voter List, and Left Out the Party That Sued.



Comments
Every comment is read by a person before it appears, so yours will not show straight away. We publish comments that are civil and on the subject. To report a mistake in the piece, use the corrections page, so it is fixed in the piece itself.