The Field
AnalysisGovernanceDeveloping

Galmudug's Rerun Kept the Same Referee and the Same Voter List, and Left Out the Party That Sued

Somalia's Supreme Court threw out Galmudug's July 30 vote. On September 30 the state voted again, run by the same commission, from the same register, without the party that won the case.

A woman in a grey headscarf and white face mask, with an election badge on a blue lanyard, drops a ballot into a blue plastic ballot box.
A delegate casts her vote in the South West State parliamentary election in Baidoa on 25 January 2022. File photo from a different state and vote, not from Galmudug's rerun.Photo: AMISOM Public Information, via Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (public domain)
Listen to this article12 min

If the audio and the text below differ, the text is right. Report a mistake.

On Thursday, October 22, Galmudug’s House met at Dhusamareb to choose a president. A day earlier both candidates had presented their programmes. Now 89 members cast ballots, and the House Speaker, Hussein Mohamed Nur, announced the result: 72 votes for Liibaan Ahmed Hassan, known as Shuluq, of the ruling Justice and Solidarity Party (JSP), 14 for Abdulkadir Abdullahi Diriye of the opposition party Sincad, and three spoiled ballots, Dawan Africa reported. Liibaan called it a victory for the people of Galmudug, Dawan reported, and thanked the outgoing leader, Ahmed Abdi Kariye, known as Qoor Qoor, for a peaceful election, and the rival groups that had backed him. The JSP holds 67 of the House’s 89 seats, so he won five more votes than his party has members. President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud and Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre congratulated him, and the prime minister called the vote transparent.

It was the end of a story that began in July, when the Supreme Court threw out the state’s first election and ordered another. The court’s reasons were about how the vote was run, and it was fair to ask what would change. The answer, ten weeks later, was that the paperwork changed and the machinery did not. The same commission ran the rerun from the same voter register, and it left out the party that had sued. The ruling party’s candidate then became president in a House it controls. That is the argument of this piece: the court corrected a process, but it did not change who runs the election or who benefits from it, and Galmudug’s court case should not be read as proof that Somalia’s courts can keep a vote fair.

How the court threw out the first vote

Galmudug is one of three states where President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s government has pressed hard on who governs. South West’s president, Abdiaziz Laftagareen, defied Villa Somalia, the presidential palace in Mogadishu, and held his own re-election on March 28. Federal troops took Baidoa within 48 hours. He resigned that day and fled to Nairobi. Galmudug’s president, Qoor Qoor, left more quietly. The Somali Guardian reported on May 23 that the president had endorsed Liibaan, whose earlier profile I described as a businessman who had never run for office. On June 25 Qoor Qoor said he would not seek re-election, after talks involving the intelligence chief and the prime minister, and three days later the ruling party named Liibaan as its sole candidate. I traced both exits in my September 3 investigation.

Galmudug’s version then ran into something South West’s never did: a court. The party Towfiiq, the state’s main opposition force, petitioned the Supreme Court, and a five-judge bench led by Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed heard argument from August 17 to 19 and ruled on August 24. The commission, the National Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (NIEBC), fought the case and asked the court to confirm the results. The court refused. It was the first annulment of Galmudug results since direct voting began, according to allAfrica.

The 23-page judgment went through the process stage by stage. The commission had moved polling day from July 20 to July 25 and then to July 30, leaving too little time for parties, candidates and voters. Registration was still running two days before the vote. Party representatives were turned away from some polling stations, and voter cards were short or irregular. The court called the violations substantial, not technical, and said failures at different stages can add up and destroy confidence in the result. It ordered fresh elections for the state House and local councils, and told the current institutions to stay in office until replacements are elected, with no date.

The commission had given the JSP 63 of 89 seats and Towfiiq 12. Towfiiq said its own agents recorded different numbers and published a tally of 47 seats. The court did not decide who won. It ruled on how the vote was run.

What changed, and what did not

The commission published the timetable at the start of September, about 30 days before polling. Polling centres were marked on September 10. Parties had to submit their polling-station representatives by September 22, and representatives and observers were accredited on September 26. That answers the court’s findings on barred party agents with a dated accreditation step, and the commission accepted the ruling publicly without trying to stall.

Four things stayed the same. The referee is the first. NIEBC ran the July vote, defended it in court, and organised the rerun. According to one outlet, the court attached no outside supervisor to enforce its standards, which I could not confirm independently. The voter list is the second. The commission said 270,737 people registered for July, and the same register was used again. The court did not declare the register invalid. It said the commission had not shown full compliance with the procedures around it, so the rerun started from the list the court said the commission had not shown it handled properly. The Somali Digest gives a different enrolment figure, 215,860, without explaining the gap, so I cannot say which is right. The notice is the third: July’s timetable gave too little preparation time, and the rerun gave about 30 days, which meets the legal minimum only if the full judgment says so. The date is the fourth. The commission picked September 30, the same day Hirshabelle voted, and ran two states at once. One local outlet questioned its capacity to do that.

The commission also excluded the party that sued. It says Towfiiq missed the September 12 deadline to submit candidates. Towfiiq says the commission already held its lists, that it learned of the exclusion from social media, and that the move is punishment for suing. It asked the commission to reverse the decision on September 26 and had no answer as of September 27. The dispute hinges on whether Towfiiq’s list reached the commission on time, which the published record does not clarify. Its support is concentrated in Dhusamareb and Guriceel.

The result, and what the court’s approval means

On the day of the rerun Liibaan voted in Galkayo and praised the long queues. The commission announced results on October 2, the Somali Digest reported. The JSP won 67 of 89 House seats (110,072 of 146,374 valid votes) and 179 of 243 council seats, from 149,475 ballots cast. Against the 270,737 registered for July, that is about 55 percent by my calculation, though the Digest’s smaller register would make it about 69 percent. The commission gave no turnout figure. Its chairman, Abdikarim Ahmed Hassan, later said nearly 200,000 people voted, and I have not seen the commission explain the gap with 149,475. The JSP gained four House seats on July’s 63, but its council votes fell from 135,247 to 105,716. July figures differ between outlets, so I treat that comparison with care. Some outlets’ seat tables do not add up, so I use only the JSP’s figures.

On October 13 a five-judge panel of the Supreme Court confirmed all 89 seats, Dawan Africa reported, citing no admissible complaints under Article 73 of the National Elections Law. The court that voided the first election signed off on the second. That shows less than it sounds like. A court can only rule on what is brought to it, and the party that brought the July case was not on the September ballot. The approval shows that no admissible complaint reached the court. It does not show that every weakness the judges listed in August was removed.

The members were sworn in on October 16. On October 18 the JSP’s Hussein Mohamed Nur Mohamed won the speaker vote, beating Sincad’s Ismail Abdi Jimale Alasow, FTL Somalia reported; the Digest gives him 79 votes and says two JSP deputy speakers were elected unopposed with 87 each. Four days later came the presidential vote. The vice president was the JSP’s Senator Abdiweli Ibrahim Aden, known as Garyare, against Sincad’s Abdisatar Mohamed Geelle. Dawan reports the count as 66 votes to 20, FTL as 64 to 22, and WardheerNews as 64 for Garyare, and I could not resolve the difference. FTL says Diriye accepted the result, and no other outlet I read reports that. I have not found a swearing-in date or a cabinet. Under the court’s order, Qoor Qoor’s administration stays until a successor is lawfully elected.

Could it have gone differently?

The court could have attached a supervisor, or ordered the register re-verified and published, as a condition of the rerun. That would have turned a finding about the past into a rule for the future. The commission could have invited Towfiiq in on terms, or published the proof that its list was late, which would have taken the exclusion out of the realm of suspicion. Towfiiq, which won the case, might have filed its list earlier or in a way no one could contest, though it says the commission already held its lists. The government could have left the choice of candidate to the party without a presidential endorsement a month before the incumbent stepped aside, as the Somali Guardian reported. None of this required a different court. It required a decision to treat the court’s reasoning as a standard and not as a repair.

The best case for the commission

The strongest objection is that the commission did what a body in its position can do. It accepted the ruling, shortened the delay, put agents’ accreditation on a timetable, and held the vote again within six weeks. The court then approved it, and the result of a House election in which the ruling party wins 67 of 89 seats is not shocking in a state where it governs. The extra votes for the winner are a small sign that not everything ran along party lines. That is a fair argument. But it describes a commission that is competent, not one that is independent of the people who benefit from the result, and the test of independence is whether it publishes what lets others check it: station-by-station returns, the register and the reason a party was left out.

Whether the commission publishes station-by-station returns, which would let Towfiiq and others compare the official numbers with their agents’ sheets, is the point of contention that began in July. How the new government treats the excluded party is the other. This mirrors the thesis of The Guarantee: the ballot box is open, but the political field is narrowed. The opposition’s reaction to the result, including the congratulations from former Prime Minister Mohamed Hussein Roble and others, is a separate story.

In August the Supreme Court said that a failure at one stage can sink a whole election. In October, at Dhusamareb, 72 members of a House the ruling party controls chose a president the ruling party had picked in May. Whether that vote reached the standard the court set is a question that only published returns can answer.

Read the companion story: Galmudug’s Court Case Is a Checklist. Hirshabelle’s Election Only Partly Passes It.

Follow The FieldFacebookXLinkedIn

Report an error in this story How we correct: Corrections

Updates to this piece

  • October 25, 2026. Rebuilt as a narrative with the October 22 presidential vote at Dhusamareb as the opening. Added the president's earlier endorsement on May 23, the speaker vote and the open questions on turnout and the register. Earlier: certified results (Oct 13), oath (Oct 16).
Archived copies of the sources linked in this piece (5)

Links to the Internet Archive's saved copy of each page, in case the original changes or disappears. somaliatoday.com · dawan.africa · somalidispatch.com · wardheernews.com · hornobserver.com

Ismail Abukar

Ismail Abukar

Founder and editor of The Field. Independent investigative journalist.

Ismail Abukar is an independent investigative journalist. Over seven years of primary field research inside Somalia's prisons and military courts, including about 500 interviews with convicted Al-Shabaab operatives and a review of 400 military court cases, he has reported on Al-Shabaab, arbitrary detention and political accountability. His investigations have been published by Lawfare, African Arguments, Horn Observer and Pambazuka News, and his research has been cited by Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the U.S. State Department. He holds an MA in International Law and Human Rights from UPEACE (2021). He founded The Field to give reporters who were there a place to publish. He is also co-founder and chairperson of the Organization for Prisoners' Rights (OPR), a separate nonprofit in Mogadishu that has no role in funding or editing The Field.

Reporting from anywhere in the world? Write for us.

If you were there and you hold the evidence, send us a pitch. We reply within 48 hours and aim to publish within 72 hours of your approval of the final edit.

Write for us: pitch a story

Follow The Field by email

New stories and important updates, sent to you. We will not share your address. You can also follow us by RSS.

We use your address only to send you The Field. See our privacy page.

Read next

AnalysisGovernanceDeveloping

An 81-to-13 Win Does Not Settle Hirshabelle's Hawadle Dispute

The ruling party's candidate won the state presidency on October 24, as in Galmudug. The Supreme Court had certified the House results, and no challenge was filed. The Hawadle grievances that dominated the buildup are unresolved.

By The Field  |  October 25, 2026  |  5 min read

Other recent checks All recent →

Story checks from the past seven days, each with the date it was checked. The trackers and the midterms page have their own checks, listed below.

    No other story checks in the past seven days. The most recent was November 4, 2026, at 12:00 EAT.

    Tracker checks are listed separately. Ethiopia war: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · Sudan war: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · Yemen war and the Houthis: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · U.S. midterms: page last updated .