The Field
AnalysisHuman rightsDeveloping

"We Followed the Protocol" Is Not a Defense When Christa Pike Survived Two Doses

Tennessee says it followed every step when it gave Christa Pike two doses of pentobarbital and she survived. The protocol it followed has no answer for a failed IV line, allows the commissioner to deviate, and was used a second time by the same physician after the Carruthers attempt in May. A review led by Ed Stanton has no reported deadline.

The Tennessee State Capitol in Nashville: a pale stone building with a columned front and a square tower topped by a small round cupola, seen from below under a cloudy sky.
The Tennessee State Capitol in Nashville. File photo, not from the events described.Photo: Kaldari, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain
Listen to this article12 min

If the audio and the text below differ, the text is right. Report a mistake.

For about 45 minutes on the evening of September 30, the curtain in the viewing room at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville stayed closed. The media witnesses had come in at 6:41, and reporters who had covered earlier Tennessee executions called the wait unusual. When it opened at about 7:26, Christa Pike told the room she was at peace. At about 7:35 she said her arm felt like it was about to burst and asked whether that was normal. The curtain dropped at 7:46 and reopened three minutes later, when she began to snore loudly. It closed for the last time at 8:05, and the witnesses heard her rhythmic snoring until they were escorted out at 8:53. Pike was not dead. She had been given two doses of pentobarbital, and she survived them.

Tennessee has said it followed its protocol. “We followed the protocol” is not a defense but a finding. If an agency can do every step as written and still fail in front of witnesses, the document it followed is what failed, and the question for the review the governor has ordered is who wrote it, who could have changed it, and why nobody did after the first warning in May. The Field was not in the room. This draws on media witnesses, Pike’s lawyers, court filings and official statements, all linked, and the lawyers’ accounts are labelled as theirs.

The night, in order

Pike, 50, was convicted with her then-boyfriend of the 1995 killing of Colleen Slemmer, a 19-year-old fellow student, who was stabbed and beaten on the University of Tennessee’s agricultural campus in Knoxville. Pike was 18. She was due to be the first woman executed in Tennessee in more than 200 years. A federal appeals court panel stayed the execution that morning so it could review her claim that her trial lawyers failed to present evidence of her history of child sexual abuse, and the US Supreme Court overturned the stay that evening, with Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson dissenting.

What happened inside before the curtain opened comes from a declaration by Pike’s lawyer Randy Spivey, who was there. It is his account and no court has tested it. ABC News reports that the IV team began looking for a vein at 6:34, used about ten needles, and that one member said, “I think it is blown,” and another, “Let’s regroup.” At 7:24, he says, the team “seemed satisfied that the lines were set” and left the chamber. Spivey also said he counted at least seven needle sticks in her left arm alone, and that her right arm turned purple after the second round of drugs. The lawyers told the court no member of the team seems to have realized the lines were not correctly placed, Fortune reported. At 8:06, he says, her spiritual adviser whispered, “She’s still alive.” A 911 call asking for an ambulance was made from the prison at 8:40, according to a Metro Nashville emergency-communications transcript ABC cites. The lawyers say the second dose was given at about 8 p.m., and witnesses say it was given by 8:26. A source who was there told NBC News there was no oxygen or mask in the chamber and that staff had to fetch them from a prison clinic, an account The Field could not confirm elsewhere.

What the protocol says, and what it leaves out

The state’s protocol calls for a set of four syringes, two of pentobarbital and two of saline, a five-minute wait and a doctor’s check, and then a second set if the inmate is not dead, WSMV reported. After that there is nothing. The Department of Correction said it followed every step, that the drug has consistently been effective and that the protocol allows no additional procedures. It has not said what went wrong.

Yet the protocol, in the redacted manual the state released with its new rules, lets the commissioner depart from it “whenever” he deems it necessary, according to the AP, and it requires the IV team and the physician to be outside contractors, not department staff. A copy obtained by the Death Penalty Information Center says there is no deviation except by order of the commissioner. So there was a door. Nobody has said whether anyone considered opening it at 7:07, when a line was thought to be blown, or at 8:06. The Field could not open the protocol itself and found nothing in the coverage on its provisions for a central line, a tube placed in a large vein.

The second failure

This was not the first. On May 21, officials called off the execution of Tony Carruthers after more than an hour of failed attempts to establish IV access, and Governor Bill Lee granted a one-year reprieve. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, the protocol’s required backup line was never placed and an attempt at a central line failed. Carruthers’s sister, Dr. Tonya Hervey, later filed a complaint with the Tennessee Department of Health alleging malpractice and torture and saying he had a stroke that left him partially paralyzed. Those are her allegations, and the department has not ruled on them.

The physician in that attempt, Dr. Mark Fowler, was also the overseeing physician for Pike’s execution, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. In a deposition that WSMV reported in July, he said he had placed a central line a dozen or more times but not since about 2013, and described an earlier complication in which the guide wire “wound up in the carotid vein, which is an undesirable placement.” WSMV does not say which procedure, and the deposition appears to predate the Carruthers attempt. What he did on September 30 has not been made public.

Warnings came before Pike’s date, too. Nine Republican state senators asked Lee for an independent review in June. In July, more than 50 medical professionals urged him to suspend executions. Pike’s own lawsuit, reported by the Death Penalty Information Center in January, said she has small veins that make inserting a needle difficult and listed a blood-clotting condition. Lee ordered a review only after Pike survived, and halted the one remaining 2026 execution, that of Gary Wayne Sutton on December 3.

Who is reviewing whom

Lee’s office announced that Department of Correction Commissioner Frank Strada would step down, with an effective date of “this month” and no successor named in anything The Field found, ABC News reported. Strada said he believed the department had followed its protocol. The review is led by former US Attorney Ed Stanton, retained by the Attorney General’s office, NewsChannel 9 reported. No deadline has been reported. Reports say he also led a review in 2022 that led to the protocol’s last rewrite, so he is being asked, in part, to assess a system he helped fix once before. That is not a reason to doubt him. It is a reason for his terms to be published.

The courts are moving slowly. On October 7, Chancellor I’Ashea Myles ordered the state to preserve evidence of the attempt, NewsChannel 5 reported, including drugs, syringes, IV lines, needles, restraints and gurneys, plus notes, timelines and any photographs, video and audio from the execution and witness rooms. The judge put Pike’s lawsuit over the protocol back on the docket on October 8, and ordered the state to give her its prison policies on medical transfers, visitation and tablets. An October 23 hearing on the state’s request to set a deadline for Pike to amend her complaint was removed from the docket, Fox 17 reported, and the judge will decide on the written filings. No ruling has been reported. In a separate suit, other death-row prisoners moved on October 22 to add Carruthers and Pike to their challenge, with a hearing on November 6, NewsChannel 5 reported.

Can the state try again?

Lee denied clemency on September 28, before the attempt. Pike’s lawyers now ask him to commute her sentence to life without parole, ABC News reported. The state’s lawyer told the court on October 7 that the decision on a new date belongs to the Tennessee Supreme Court, which set Pike’s date, and said he could not answer whether she would be scheduled again. Her lawyer Luke Ihnen said the state “has made no promises.”

The law is not on her side by default. In Francis v. Resweber in 1947, the US Supreme Court let Louisiana try again after an electric chair failed to kill a teenager, and law professors Eric Berger and Austin Sarat told Newsweek that case is the key precedent and that an Eighth Amendment claim is “a long shot.” Berger said the likelier challenge is competency, since “if she suffered brain damage, she may not be competent to be executed,” and Sarat noted that Francis survived an unforeseeable accident while Pike’s lawyers had warned of complications in advance. Ohio’s attempt on Romell Broom in 2009 failed after two hours and at least 18 needle sticks with no drug entering his body; the state Supreme Court let it retry him by a 4-3 vote in 2016, and he died in 2020 of probable Covid, aged 64, never re-executed, CNN and ClickOrlando reported. Pike is the first to survive the drugs themselves, the Death Penalty Information Center says.

And her condition? Her lawyers say she woke on October 6 and was discharged from the hospital on October 10 to the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, where she has lived for more than 30 years. On October 8 they described her walking with help, pneumonia, a clot in her arm, severe burns and problems with memory and concentration, and said doctors will need months to know whether the cognitive damage lasts. Those are the lawyers’ statements. The department does not comment on pending litigation, and The Field found nothing on whether restraints continue.

The best case for the state

The strongest objection is that this is a failure of method, not of the sentence. A jury sentenced a woman to death for a killing that left a 19-year-old dead, courts upheld the sentence for 30 years, and the family has waited all that time. Slemmer’s mother, May Martinez, told NBC News the night was “a mess.” The state can argue that its staff followed rules, that an execution team can’t be blamed for a human vein, and that a better protocol will fix it. That is a fair argument, and it is the argument that the review should test. But “followed the protocol” cannot be both the defense and the finding. If the steps were followed and the person lived, the steps need to change, and the public is owed the new ones before the next date is set.

The sentence itself is also contested on grounds that have nothing to do with veins. Pike’s lawyers say her trial counsel never told the jury about her childhood sexual abuse. The Sixth Circuit’s 2-1 stay turned on that claim, and the dissent quoted the state conceding that it does “not dispute the terrible things that Ms. Pike suffered”. The Supreme Court vacated the stay, and The Field found no ruling on the merits of that claim.

What I do not know

The Field does not know what Fowler did on September 30, what the protocol says about central lines, whether the commissioner was asked to deviate, or whether oxygen was really missing. It does not know when the review will report, who will lead the department, whether Lee will act on clemency before he leaves, or when the state will ask for another date. The Field emailed the department’s communications office on October 10 with four questions, and the reply note above records what it has said.

The curtain in the viewing room closed for the last time at 8:05. What happened behind it is known to the execution team, the physician and the state, and only the state can say whether it will ever tell us.

Follow The FieldFacebookXLinkedIn

Report an error in this story How we correct: Corrections

Updates to this piece

  • October 26, 2026. Rebuilt as an analysis of the protocol and the accountability gap; folded in the October 3, 6, 7, 10, 19 and 22 updates; added the Spivey declaration timeline, the Fowler deposition, the November 6 hearing and the Francis and Broom precedents; no ruling, new execution date or Stanton findings found since October 22.
  • October 22, 2026. Oct 23 chancery hearing removed from docket, state's motion to be decided on paper; lawyers report Pike speaking in full sentences; no state statement or new execution date.
  • October 22, 2026. Replaced two source links that could not be checked.

The Field

News desk

The Field is an independent accountability-journalism site covering every region of the world. Pieces under this byline are news reports and status updates compiled from published reporting and official statements, checked and edited by The Field's editor, Ismail Abukar.

Reporting from anywhere in the world? Write for us.

If you were there and you hold the evidence, send us a pitch. We reply within 48 hours and aim to publish within 72 hours of your approval of the final edit.

Write for us: pitch a story

Follow The Field by email

New stories and important updates, sent to you. We will not share your address. You can also follow us by RSS.

We use your address only to send you The Field. See our privacy page.

Other recent checks All recent →

Story checks from the past seven days, each with the date it was checked. The trackers and the midterms page have their own checks, listed below.

    No other story checks in the past seven days. The most recent was November 4, 2026, at 12:00 EAT.

    Tracker checks are listed separately. Ethiopia war: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · Sudan war: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · Yemen war and the Houthis: last checked November 10, 2026, at 20:45 EAT · U.S. midterms: page last updated .